Review a statistic excel spreadsheet

[JBlixt]

I put together a spreadsheet to keep statistics and analyze sit and go results.

I Would appriciate if you could take a while to review it and see if you think it is a good tool or if we missed something.

I am also going to do one for ring games and MTT. But before I continue it would be great to have some input if we do the right thing or not.

The file is to large to upload here so I have to post the link. It is a zip file to make it faster to download.
http://www.pokerbeginner.org/sit/go/statistics.htm

Let us know what you think!

[kaus]

I downloaded it and will look in a bit but I thought I would let you know that your link in the top nav for home is mucked up.

[ThePokerBank]

Had a look, and it seems pretty good. I had some sort of error pop up when I loaded it, can't remember what it said but it made no difference I dont think to the way it works, but just a heads up.

But anyways, few things...

1) Add a few more buy-in variables, or maybe just allow players to enter their own buy-ins manually. There is a greater variety of buy-ins than you have provided in the sit n go world.

2) What does dep/with mean?

3) I imagine you would want to add the bonus amount to your final bankroll.

4) What do I do if I already have a bankroll of X amount?

5) The 'variation' collumn is quite thin and so I cant see the full word. It makes no difference to the way it works but I guess it would make things look tidier.


I think thats everything, but theyre only minors things. So although i pointed out a number of things I don't think its a poor job. I think you have done a great job and it works really efficiently. Nicely done.

If I were to add one more thing, maybe play with the look of the whole thing. It looks okay, but not amazing. But then again I guess excel wasn't really made for design work.

Touch up a few things and this could work really well.

[JBlixt]

Originally Posted by ThePokerBank

Had a look, and it seems pretty good. I had some sort of error pop up when I loaded it, can't remember what it said but it made no difference I dont think to the way it works, but just a heads up.

But anyways, few things...

1) Add a few more buy-in variables, or maybe just allow players to enter their own buy-ins manually. There is a greater variety of buy-ins than you have provided in the sit n go world.

2) What does dep/with mean?

3) I imagine you would want to add the bonus amount to your final bankroll.

4) What do I do if I already have a bankroll of X amount?

5) The 'variation' collumn is quite thin and so I cant see the full word. It makes no difference to the way it works but I guess it would make things look tidier.


I think thats everything, but theyre only minors things. So although i pointed out a number of things I don't think its a poor job. I think you have done a great job and it works really efficiently. Nicely done.

If I were to add one more thing, maybe play with the look of the whole thing. It looks okay, but not amazing. But then again I guess excel wasn't really made for design work.

Touch up a few things and this could work really well.

Thank you for your review and nice words. I will try to improve it as much as I can. But most of this info are already presented in the info page. It can alwyas be more user friendly and that is what I am looking for.

Most of your questions are answered in the info page (or at least I tried to) but it can always be a lot better and maybe easier to understand.

Your points:
1) You can add your own buy in levels in the second page; blue fields. Then they will show up in the list where you put in your values.
2) dep/with are short for deposit and withdrawal. You need them to keep track of your bankroll.
3) Yes, bonuses are included in the final bankroll.
4) Your starting bankroll are meant to be added on the start page; it says bankroll at start.
5) Point taken.