I like it, the little mouth with legs made me laugh.

My boyfriend said he thought it should be black and red, because "Full Tilt is so black and red." I think he strongly links the the Mouth and FTP, though... but he is probably a good indicator of the average guy's perspective of the page.
I think the three-column layout looks nice, as well. I also am on the fence about the color scheme. I think it's all right, but something about it seems not quite right. I'm sure that's exactly the sort of constructive feedback you're seeking.
Overall though, I think it's got a nice look and feel.