Now we're on the same page PPP, I think? lol
I agree 100% that cardplayer should get it in scenario #2
Not sure WTF the cookie on leaving BS was about? I didn't even comment on it.
The only thing that makes any sense whatsoever to me is...
Link gets clicked, new cookie gets set, finish transaction, the owner of the link that actually initiated the transaction that results in a reg gets rewarded.
I'm going to be sure to notify all rooms I'm promoting & get an approval on whatever I come up with. No more tracking soup for me, have had my fill

Cheers